Understanding the Proposal

Frequently Asked Questions

Merit-Based Football proposes a new competitive structure for college football built around promotion and relegation. This FAQ answers the most common questions about the basic concept, the 30-league system, scheduling, player compensation, competitive balance, financial sustainability, and what would be required to turn the proposal into a real-world competition.

426 Programs 30 Leagues 3 Up / 3 Down 1 National Champion

426 Programs
30 Connected Leagues
3 ↑ / 3 ↓ Promotion & Relegation
1 National Champion

Section 01

The Basic Idea

Start here: what Merit-Based Football is, why it exists, and which programs are included.

01 What is Merit-Based Football?

Merit-Based Football, or MBF, is a proposal to reorganize college football into one connected national competition consisting of 426 programs and 30 competitive leagues.

Teams move up or down through promotion and relegation based on performance. League 1 is the highest level, and its champion is the national champion.

Instead of permanently separating programs by conference prestige or historical subdivision, MBF creates a competitive ladder in which every participating program has a defined pathway upward.

02 Why change the current college-football system?

College football has become an increasingly commercial sport, but access to the highest competitive level remains heavily influenced by conference membership, institutional resources, historical prestige, and relationships with the most powerful leagues.

A successful program outside that structure may have no automatic path to compete at the highest level.

MBF attempts to replace that largely fixed hierarchy with one in which advancement can be earned on the field. Strong programs rise, struggling programs can fall, and teams throughout the structure have meaningful competitive objectives.

03 What does promotion and relegation mean?

Promotion and relegation allow teams to move between competitive levels after each season.

In MBF, the top three teams in a league are promoted to the league immediately above them, while the bottom three are relegated to the league immediately below.

For example, three teams could move from League 8 to League 7 while three League 7 teams move to League 8. League 1 is the highest level, and League 30 is the bottom of the current structure.

04 How is MBF fundamentally different from today's conference system?

Today's conferences generally have fixed membership. Programs do not normally move to stronger or weaker conferences simply because of their win-loss records.

MBF makes competitive position fluid.

Conference invitations, television value, historical prestige, and institutional relationships would no longer determine whether a team has a pathway upward. Repeated success could move a program higher, while repeated poor performance could move even a nationally prominent program downward.

The system is organized primarily around competitive merit rather than permanent membership status.

05 Which college-football programs are included?

The proposed starting system contains 426 programs:

  • 138 programs in the project's FBS group;
  • 127 remaining FCS programs; and
  • 161 Division II programs.

Those teams are combined into one competitive structure rather than remaining permanently separated by today's subdivision boundaries.

The 426-team model represents the proposed starting field. Future expansion, membership standards, and admission of additional programs would require separate rules.

Section 02

The 30-League Structure

How 426 programs become one interconnected competitive ladder.

06 Why are there 30 leagues?

Thirty leagues allow all 426 programs to participate while keeping nearly every competitive level at 14 teams.

That size supports one of MBF's central scheduling features: a full round robin in which every team in a standard 14-team league plays every other team once.

Thirty levels also create gradual movement. A program does not jump from the bottom of college football directly to the national-championship level overnight. It must progress through increasingly difficult competition.

07 Why do Leagues 1 through 29 contain 14 teams?

With 14 teams, each program can play the other 13 members exactly once.

That creates a 13-game league round robin and gives teams competing for promotion, relegation, or a championship a highly comparable schedule.

It also reduces scheduling disparities caused when teams competing in the same conference do not play one another and are later compared through complicated tiebreakers or subjective strength-of-schedule judgments.

08 Why does League 30 contain 20 teams?

After placing 14 teams in each of the first 29 leagues, 20 programs remain from the 426-team field.

Those teams form League 30 rather than forcing substantial changes to the structure of the other leagues.

League 30 may be administered as League 30A and League 30B for scheduling and operational purposes. The precise mechanics of that arrangement remain subject to refinement.

09 Would FBS, FCS, and Division II classifications still determine competitive status?

No. Not within MBF competition.

Those classifications are useful for identifying the programs included in the initial structure and helping establish their starting positions.

Once MBF begins, a team's league becomes its competitive level. A former Division II or FCS program could eventually rise above former FBS programs, while an established FBS program could fall below them.

Historical subdivision status would therefore cease to function as a permanent competitive ceiling or floor.

10 How are teams placed into the initial 30 leagues?

A promotion-and-relegation system needs an initial order before it can begin using MBF results.

The project's 2025 FBS, FCS, and Division II rankings provide the starting competitive information used to organize the 426 programs.

Those rankings are an initialization mechanism, not a permanent hierarchy. Once MBF competition begins, future league position is earned through results rather than repeatedly reassigned through outside rankings.

The core principle: Rankings start the system. Results run it.

Section 03

Promotion, Relegation & the National Championship

How teams rise, fall, and ultimately win the national title.

11 How many teams are promoted and relegated each season?

Three teams move upward and three move downward between adjacent leagues after each season.

That creates meaningful annual movement while preserving enough continuity for leagues to develop recognizable competitive identities.

Across 30 levels, promotion races and relegation battles would give many more teams meaningful late-season objectives than a system focused primarily on a small number of championship contenders.

12 What determines whether a team is promoted or relegated?

Competitive results determine movement.

Advancement is intended to be earned through performance rather than a school's attendance, television audience, stadium capacity, donor base, historical championships, conference affiliation, or institutional reputation.

Those factors may still give programs advantages in other ways, but they do not protect a team from relegation or substitute for the results necessary to earn promotion.

13 Could a traditional powerhouse really be relegated?

Yes.

Historical reputation does not provide immunity from relegation.

A major program would not suddenly fall ten levels because of one bad season. Movement normally occurs one league at a time. But repeated bottom-three finishes could progressively move even a famous program downward.

That possibility is essential to the concept. A system cannot credibly reward merit while permanently protecting historically powerful programs from the competitive consequences of poor performance.

14 Could an FCS or Division II program eventually reach League 1?

Yes.

That is one of MBF's defining differences from the current structure.

A program beginning well below League 1 could earn successive promotions and eventually compete at the highest level. It would not need an invitation from a prestigious conference to continue advancing.

The path would be difficult and potentially lengthy, but it would exist for every participating program.

15 How long could it take a team to reach League 1?

Because teams normally move only one league per season, the minimum theoretical climb depends on where the program starts.

A League 10 team would need nine promotions to reach League 1. A team beginning much lower would require considerably longer.

Consecutive promotions also become increasingly difficult as the quality of competition rises.

MBF promises an open pathway, not an easy pathway.
16 What happens at the bottom of League 30?

League 30 is the bottom of the current 426-team MBF structure, so there is presently no lower MBF league into which its bottom teams would be relegated.

The system could eventually establish an entry mechanism if additional qualified programs sought membership, but rules for expansion, admission, and possible movement below League 30 have not yet been formally developed.

17 How is the national champion determined?

The League 1 winner is the national champion.

League 1's 14 teams play one another in a complete 13-game round robin. The team finishing first therefore earns the national title through competition against every other team at the highest level.

No selection committee is needed to choose championship participants, and no separate playoff is required to determine the champion under the current proposal.

League 1 winner = National Champion
18 What happens if League 1 teams finish tied?

League standings would require a formal tiebreaking procedure.

Head-to-head results are an obvious component because tied teams in a 14-team round robin would have played one another.

The complete sequence of additional tiebreakers has not yet been formally adopted. Rather than inventing rules prematurely, MBF would need a transparent tiebreaking system as part of its eventual competition rulebook.

19 Why doesn't MBF use a playoff?

MBF is designed around the principle that the regular season should determine the championship.

Every League 1 team plays every other League 1 team. That differs fundamentally from a system in which championship contenders play substantially different schedules and then require a selection process or playoff to compare them.

The absence of a playoff also spreads meaningful late-season competition throughout the structure. Teams may be fighting for the national title, promotion, survival, or avoidance of relegation.

20 What happens to bowl games?

The current MBF proposal does not include traditional postseason bowl games.

The 13-game round-robin season is intended to be the central competition, with the League 1 standings determining the national champion and league standings throughout the structure determining promotion and relegation.

This is a major departure from college-football tradition and carries real tradeoffs. MBF's current priority is a complete, meaningful league season rather than preserving a separate postseason exhibition structure.

Section 04

Scheduling, Rivalries, Geography & Rankings

How the competitive calendar works and where the proposal accepts genuine tradeoffs.

21 Why does each team play 13 league games?

A 14-team league naturally produces a 13-game round robin.

Every team therefore faces every other team in its competitive level once.

That creates a straightforward way to determine which programs deserve promotion, which should remain, and which should be relegated. It also makes standings easier to understand because teams are compared after facing essentially the same group of opponents.

22 Would MBF eliminate traditional nonconference "buy games"?

Under the proposed schedule, yes.

The 13-game round robin fills the regular season with games against teams occupying the same competitive level. There is therefore no normal place for a powerful program to pay a substantially weaker opponent to visit for a nonconference game.

MBF deliberately favors more competitively balanced matchups.

The tradeoff is that some dramatic upsets created by mismatched nonconference games would disappear. In exchange, promotion and relegation would create different forms of regular-season drama.

23 What happens to traditional rivalries?

Some rivalries would continue naturally when both teams occupy the same league.

Others could be interrupted if one program is promoted or relegated while the other remains behind.

That is a genuine tradeoff. Guaranteeing every historical rivalry every year would conflict with a complete 13-game league round robin.

Tradition and geography can influence scheduling where the competitive structure permits it, but they cannot override promotion and relegation without weakening the merit-based principle.

24 Would a national pyramid create excessive travel?

Potentially, particularly in leagues whose membership is geographically dispersed.

MBF prioritizes competitive level over permanent geographic conferences, so travel cannot always be minimized.

Travel costs, recovery time, scheduling efficiency, and player welfare would need serious attention. Central operating distributions are intended in part to help make participation feasible for programs that could not independently absorb sharply higher travel expenses.

Geography should be managed intelligently wherever possible without allowing it to recreate permanently protected regional conferences.

25 Do rankings continue to determine league position after MBF begins?

No.

Rankings are necessary to create the initial starting structure because no MBF results yet exist.

After competition begins, promotion and relegation replace rankings as the mechanism for movement.

A team would not lose a promotion because an outside ranking system considered another program better, nor would a poorly performing team be protected because computer rankings or opinion polls still viewed it favorably.

Rankings initialize MBF. They do not govern MBF once competition begins.

Section 05

Players, Rosters, NIL & Compensation

How the proposal addresses direct pay, roster limits, player mobility, NIL, depth, and competitive balance.

26 Would Merit-Based Football players be paid?

Yes.

Every rostered player would receive guaranteed cash compensation based on the competitive league in which the player's program participates.

The current base model provides salaries ranging from approximately $30,000 per player in League 30 to $300,000 per player in League 1, with progressively higher compensation as teams move upward.

Scheduled guaranteed player payroll across the 426-team system is approximately $3.184 billion annually under the current base model.

These figures are planning assumptions within the proposed financial model, not contractual commitments already adopted by participating universities.

27 Why does player compensation differ by league?

MBF attempts to balance three objectives: providing meaningful compensation throughout the system, remaining financially sustainable in the lower leagues, and offering sufficiently strong compensation at the top to compete for elite players.

A single salary across all 30 levels would make that difficult.

The compensation scale therefore increases as the competitive and commercial level rises. Promotion carries an economic reward as well as a sporting one.

28 How much would League 30 players receive?

The current recommended minimum is approximately $30,000 in guaranteed annual cash compensation per player.

With 85 players, that represents approximately $2.55 million in base player payroll per League 30 program.

The $30,000 figure refers to cash compensation only. Tuition and other educational, medical, housing, nutritional, training, insurance, and player-support benefits are separate.

The goal is to ensure that even players at the bottom of the MBF structure receive meaningful direct compensation.

29 How much would League 1 players receive?

The proposed League 1 base salary is approximately $300,000 per player.

For an 85-player roster, that produces approximately $25.5 million in standardized base player payroll per program.

That figure is not necessarily a player's maximum income. A highly marketable player could also earn legitimate NIL compensation and potentially receive governed supplemental compensation available under the broader player-compensation model.

30 What happens to salaries when a team is promoted or relegated?

The team's new league salary scale would apply for the next football contract year.

Players on a promoted team therefore move to the higher standardized salary level. Players on a relegated team move to the salary schedule associated with the lower league.

Compensation already earned for the completed season would not be taken away.

The current model does not rely on permanent parachute payments to preserve a relegated team's previous payroll.

31 Are tuition, housing, meals, healthcare, and other benefits included in those salary figures?

No.

The quoted MBF salaries represent cash compensation.

Educational and player benefits, including applicable tuition, fees, housing, meals, academic support, healthcare, rehabilitation, strength and conditioning, training, and insurance, are treated separately.

That distinction matters when comparing MBF compensation with other college-football arrangements. A player's salary would be only one component of the overall package.

32 Would players still be allowed to earn NIL income?

Yes.

Legitimate name, image, and likeness, or NIL, opportunities would remain available.

Players could earn additional income through genuine endorsements, advertising, appearances, social-media partnerships, licensing, autographs, camps, and similar commercial activity.

MBF would seek safeguards against using supposedly independent NIL transactions as disguised institutional payroll or recruiting payments.

The objective is to preserve genuine individual market opportunities without allowing NIL to completely undermine standardized team compensation.

33 Why does every team have an 85-player hard roster limit?

The 85-player maximum serves two purposes: competitive balance and financial sustainability.

Across 426 programs, it creates 36,210 roster positions.

A larger 105-player model would create 8,520 additional positions and substantially increase salaries as well as healthcare, insurance, equipment, meals, travel, academic support, and other costs.

Competitive balance matters just as much. A hard cap limits the ability of powerful programs to stockpile large numbers of talented players who might receive meaningful playing time elsewhere.

85 players × 426 programs = 36,210 roster positions
34 Is 85 players enough for a sport with so many injuries?

It should provide reasonable roster depth under ordinary circumstances, but the concern is legitimate.

Football places particularly demanding depth requirements on positions such as the offensive line, defensive line, quarterback, and special teams. A severe cluster of injuries could significantly strain an 85-player roster.

The current proposal therefore retains the hard cap while calling for continuing review of injury rates, player workloads, games missed, position shortages, and other safety indicators.

If evidence demonstrates that the policy creates unacceptable player-safety problems, the rule should be reconsidered.

35 Do injured players count against the 85-player limit?

Yes.

The current proposal has no additional injured-reserve roster, developmental roster, practice squad, taxi squad, or unrestricted walk-on roster outside the 85-player limit.

An injured player remains one of the team's 85 roster members.

That strengthens the competitive-balance and cost-control effects of the cap, but it also makes player-safety monitoring especially important.

The rule should remain subject to evidence-based review rather than being treated as untouchable.

36 Can players transfer between MBF programs?

The proposal anticipates continued player mobility, but the complete transfer system has not yet been formally developed.

MBF should not invent detailed transfer deadlines, eligibility requirements, contract rules, or restrictions before those issues receive dedicated review.

Any eventual system should balance legitimate player mobility with roster stability, competitive integrity, contractual obligations, and the interests of programs that invest significantly in player development.

37 Why might a talented player choose a lower-league program?

Playing opportunity could become a significant incentive.

Because every team is limited to 85 players, powerful programs cannot indefinitely accumulate extremely large numbers of talented backups.

A player choosing between being buried on a League 1 depth chart and becoming an important starter several levels lower may find the lower-league opportunity more attractive.

That can help spread talent throughout the 426-team system. A successful player could also contribute to a program's promotion while continuing to pursue legitimate NIL opportunities and potentially moving upward through future team success or player mobility.

Section 06

Revenue, Financial Sustainability & the Future of MBF

How the proposed economics work, what the estimates mean, and what would still be required for implementation.

38 Where would the money to operate MBF come from?

The current base model estimates approximately $11.5 billion in annual football-related revenue.

Approximately $6.4 billion would be centrally controlled, including major national media and streaming rights, national sponsorships, shared licensing, and other system-wide commercial sources.

Approximately $5.1 billion would remain primarily with individual programs through sources such as ticketing, premium seating, concessions, parking, local sponsorships, donations, and other local football revenue.

These are planning estimates, not guaranteed outcomes.

39 Is the $11.5 billion revenue estimate guaranteed?

No.

It is a base planning assumption used to test whether the proposed compensation and distribution structure could function at realistic scale.

Actual media-rights values, sponsorship revenue, attendance, economic conditions, insurance expenses, and numerous other variables could differ from projections.

For that reason, the financial framework includes reserves and periodic review rather than assuming the original estimates will remain permanently correct.

The model should evolve as reliable real-world financial information becomes available.

40 How could lower-resource programs afford player salaries and national competition?

They could not necessarily do so using only the revenues they generate today.

That is why MBF is designed financially as one interconnected national system rather than 30 independent conferences.

Central revenue would help fund player compensation, program operating distributions, medical and insurance reserves, competitive-balance measures, development compensation, and broader system stability.

Under the current base model, approximately $1.894 billion annually is directed toward program operating distributions in addition to other centrally funded protections.

The goal is to make participation viable throughout the structure rather than expecting every school to finance the same obligations from dramatically different local revenue bases.

41 Would wealthy programs still have financial advantages?

Yes.

MBF is designed to reduce certain competitive inequalities, not make every university financially identical.

Wealthier programs could still benefit from larger stadiums, stronger donor bases, superior facilities, coaching resources, established brands, local sponsorship opportunities, and larger fan bases.

The 85-player limit, standardized league salaries, centralized revenue sharing, and NIL safeguards are intended to prevent those advantages from becoming completely unrestricted roster-buying power.

Competitive balance does not require perfect financial equality. It requires reasonable limits on how easily financial strength can overwhelm sporting competition.

42 Is Merit-Based Football a finished rulebook, and how could it actually be implemented?

No. MBF is a developed structural proposal, not a finished constitution or an announcement that 426 universities have agreed to participate.

Its core framework is defined: 426 programs, 30 connected leagues, promotion and relegation, a 13-game round robin in a standard 14-team league, an 85-player hard roster limit, standardized player compensation, continued legitimate NIL opportunities, and a League 1 national champion without a separate playoff.

Real-world implementation would still require substantial work involving participating universities, governance, media agreements, player representation, labor arrangements, financial agreements, medical standards, scheduling, competition rules, legal considerations, and potentially the NCAA or another governing structure.

The proposal can also evolve as better financial, medical, operational, legal, and competitive information becomes available. Responsible revision is part of developing a workable system, not evidence that its central concept has failed.

Continue Exploring

Ready to Explore the Structure?

See how all 426 programs fit into the 30-league Merit-Based Football system.